System and method for processing receipts and other records of users

ABSTRACT

A service can perform optical character recognition (OCR) on an image of a record to determine a first set of information items about the record. A second set of information items can be identified that are likely part of the record but not determinable from performing OCR on the image. Another resource can be utilized to determine the second set of information items. A classification for the record can be determined based on first and second sets of information items. The record can be associated with a financial resource of the user based at least in part on the classification.

RELATED APPLICATIONS

This application is a continuation of U.S. patent application Ser. No.13/469,016, filed May 10, 2012 titled “SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR PROCESSINGRECEIPTS AND OTHER RECORDS OF USERS”, which claims benefit of priorityto Provisional U.S. Patent Application No. 61/484,654, filed May 10,2011 titled “SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR RECEIVING AND CLASSIFYING DATACORRESPONDING TO FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS”; the aforementioned priorityapplications are hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety forall purposes.

TECHNICAL FIELD

Embodiments described herein pertain generally to a computer-implementedsystem and method for processing receipts and other records of users.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIG. 1 illustrates a system for processing images of receipts and otherrecords of users, according to one or more embodiments.

FIG. 2 illustrates a method for determining a record depicted by animage input of the user, according to one or more embodiments.

FIG. 3 illustrates a method for managing human resources in processingtasks related to images of records, according to one or moreembodiments.

FIG. 4 illustrates a computer system on which a service such asdescribed with an embodiment of FIG. 1 may be provided.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

Embodiments described herein include a system and service for processingfor processing receipts and other records of users. In particular,embodiments described herein enable users to capture images of records(e.g., receipts, business cards, odometer readings, travel itineraries)and to submit the images so that the records are processed. The usersare able to submit their images to a service that processes the recordsappropriately, based on the classification of the record. For example,receipts can be recorded as expenses or otherwise associated withfinancial accounts or resources of the user.

According to an embodiment, a user can transmit a low quality image of arecord to a service. The service can perform optical characterrecognition (OCR) on the image to determine a first set of informationitems about the record. A second set of information items can beidentified that are likely part of the record, but not deemeddeterminable from performing OCR on the image. Another resource can beutilized to determine the second set of information items. Aclassification for the record can be determined based on first andsecond sets of information items. The record can be associated with afinancial resource of the user based at least in part on theclassification.

Embodiments as described may be implemented in the context of a systemthat aggregates financial information of a user from various sources,such as financial institutions (e.g., credit card companies). In afinancial or data aggregation context, embodiments enable users toperform activities such as uploading receipts and business cards, andthen having information from the uploaded item analyzed and aggregated.

In one embodiment, a system is provided in which information is receivedthat corresponds to an image or scanned version of a record that theuser possesses in physical form. As examples, an image can be capturedfrom a receipt, odometer reading, printed travel itinerary (or snapshotof such) or business card. In one embodiment, the image is stored in adatabase. Information captured or processed from the image can bemaintained as an electronic record, and used to classify the record.

According to one or more embodiments, images of records are obtainedfrom one or more networked devices having image capture and/or transfercapabilities. Such devices may include mobile phones, tablet computersand other devices that include camera or image capturing functionality.

In an embodiment, an electronic record is processed by a resource(programmatic, human or hybrid) in order to: (i) classify the record(e.g., receipt, what kind of receipt, business card, etc.); (ii) augmentinformation in the record with information that is determined from othersources; and/or (iii) reconcile the record with information contained ina corresponding electronic record.

Still further, in some embodiments, the electronic record is processedto identify one or more tasks. Such tasks may be generated based on theinformation provided by the user. The information is then assigned totwo or more resources, each of which classify the information as, forexample, a receipt, travel itinerary, odometer reading, or a businesscard. In some instances, a user may be charged with submitting a recordfor processing. For some kinds of records, however, some variationsprovide for the user to be credited. For example, if the image is of abusiness card with a valid email address that does not alreadycorrespond to an existing user of the system (e.g., a new referral tothe system), the credit balance associated with the user who submittedthe information is increased. Thus, alternative variations provide for areferral fee or award may be charged to the user based on certainrecords the user submits.

One or more embodiments described herein provide that methods,techniques and actions performed by a computing device are performedprogrammatically, or as a computer-implemented method. Programmaticallymeans through the use of code, or computer-executable instructions. Aprogrammatically performed step may or may not be automatic.

One or more embodiments described herein may be implemented usingprogrammatic modules or components. A programmatic module or componentmay include a program, a subroutine, a portion of a program, or asoftware component or a hardware component capable of performing one ormore stated tasks or functions. As used herein, a module or componentcan exist on a hardware component independently of other modules orcomponents. Alternatively, a module or component can be a shared elementor process of other modules, programs or machines.

Furthermore, one or more embodiments described herein may be implementedthrough the use of instructions that are executable by one or moreprocessors. These instructions may be carried on a computer-readablemedium. Machines shown or described with figures below provide examplesof processing resources and computer-readable mediums on whichinstructions for implementing embodiments of the invention can becarried and/or executed.

In particular, the numerous machines shown with embodiments of theinvention include processor(s) and various forms of memory for holdingdata and instructions. Examples of computer-readable mediums includepermanent memory storage devices, such as hard drives on personalcomputers or servers. Other examples of computer storage mediums includeportable storage units, such as CD or DVD units, flash memory (such ascarried on many cell phones and personal digital assistants (PDAs)), andmagnetic memory. Computers, terminals, network enabled devices (e.g.mobile devices such as cell phones) are all examples of machines anddevices that utilize processors, memory, and instructions stored oncomputer-readable mediums. Additionally, embodiments may be implementedin the form of computer-programs, or a computer usable carrier mediumcapable of carrying such a program.

In financial transactions, a user of the system conducts correspondenceswith another person or entity, and the submission of data correspondingto the interaction causes an account associated with the user to beeither credited or debited. In certain embodiments, the financialtransaction may be one or more of a receipt, a travel itinerary, anodometer reading, a business card or a combination thereof.

System and Service Description

FIG. 1 illustrates a system for processing images of receipts and otherrecords of users, according to one or more embodiments. A system such asdescribed by FIG. 1 may be implemented in various computingenvironments. In one embodiment, system 100 is provided as an onlineservice, supported by a server or combination of servers. Morespecifically, a system such as described by FIG. 1 is generallyimplemented under a secure computing environment, to protect financialinformation of its users. In some embodiments, users of the service mayinteract with the service using a web browser (e.g., thin ornon-client), or through a designated client application. Numerousdifferent types of computing devices operated by users are enabled tointerface with the service in order to perform activities enabled byembodiments described herein. In other implementations, alternativecomputing environments (e.g., client-centric) may be used to implementembodiments described herein.

According to some embodiments, electronic records can be created torepresent one or more financial transactions or events (e.g., images ofreceipts, odometer readings, travel itineraries), and then stored in thedatabase 120. The database 120 (or data stored therein) may beaccessible to one or more programmatic sources that can analyze orotherwise process the electronic records. In one embodiment, receiptdata is made accessible to a programmatic resource.

Still further, in certain embodiments, the programmatic sources includeone or more components or modules configured to classify, reconcile, andaugment the receipt data.

As an addition or variation, the programmatic sources may also includeinterfaces to a human workforce that can process the records in bulk todetermine select information items. For example, the human workforce canbe provided as part of Amazon Mechanical Turk.

More specifically, in some embodiments, system 100 includes componentsfor (i) enabling individuals to capture and/or transmit informationcorresponding to a record (e.g., for a financial transaction), (ii)extract and store information from the record (or image thereof), (iii)create tasks for one or more resources to extract the information,and/or (iv) credit or debit an account associated with the user thatsubmitted the record.

According to at least some embodiments, system 100 is capable ofprocessing images of records, as selected by the users of the system.The images can include low quality images of records, which can becaptured on, for example, camera phones, tablets or other portabledevices. While such devices carry functionality such as auto-focus,which makes image capture of, for example, documents possible, theimages can be difficult to programmatically decipher, as the environmentand media of the record are relatively uncontrolled. For example, a usermay capture an image of a receipt in bad lighting, or withover-lighting. Furthermore, the receipt can be wrinkled or off-center.Embodiments recognize that such variability in the images can yield topoor results from performance of OCR.

According to some embodiments, system 100 processes digital images ofrecords as submitted by its user base. Examples of records includecredit card receipts, cash receipts, sales receipts, odometer readings(or other readings from other meters), or business cards.

In certain embodiments, the computing device 101 may be a handhelddevice, such as, for example, a mobile phone, tablet or multi-functiondevice, that is connectable to a network (e.g., cellular network,Wireless Fidelity 802.11(a), (b), (g), or (n), Ethernet, the Internetetc.) to communicate with the system 100. The computing devices 101 canbe configured to capture and/or transfer one or more images of financialtransactions or events, including credit card receipts, cash receipts,vouchers, travel itineraries and fares, odometer readings, and businesscards.

In certain embodiments, the image may be a raster formatted image suchas a JPEG, PNG or GIF. In another embodiment, the image may be in avector format such as a PDF, SVG, PostScript or Adobe Illustrator.

It is also contemplated that multiple financial transactions (e.g.,multiple receipts, business cards, odometer readings, travelitineraries, etc.) may be included in a single image file. In suchcases, when the image data is analyzed, each financial transactionincluded in the image data may be processed and analyzed separately.

Although image data is specifically mentioned, it is also contemplatedthat information corresponding to the financial transaction may besubmitted and/or stored in the form of video, such as MPG, MP4, andFlash. Furthermore, it is also contemplated that each video submissionmay include multiple financial transactions (e.g. one or more receipts,odometer readings, travel itineraries, business cards or combinationsthereof). In such implementations, each distinct financial transactionincluded in the video is processed as a separate transaction.

In still yet another implementation, the financial transactioninformation may be transmitted and/or stored as audio data with the userdescribing information corresponding to one or more financialtransactions. For example, if the financial transaction corresponds to areceipt, the audio information may include a date, type of creditcard/debit card used, the amount of the transaction, the location thetransaction took place, a merchant name, etc. As with the image dataand/or video data, the audio data may include multiple financialtransactions and each financial transaction is analyzed independentlyfrom the other financial transactions.

In more detail, system 100 includes an interface 102 to communicate withcomputing devices 101 that comprise a user or subscriber base forservice provided to system 100. The interface 102 can correspond to, forexample, the website that maintains accounts for individual users. Theusers can login to a website and both submit information, includingcopies and receipts, and also view information, such as expense reports.In an embodiment, computing devices 101 communicate with system 100through the interface 102 to provide image inputs 103. Each image input103 can be received and associated with the user account. As shown in anexample, the image inputs 103 are stored in the database 120, whichmaintains information for individual user accounts. The informationmaintained for individual user accounts include, for example, (i) a userprofile (including password and login), (ii) financial accountinformation, such as credit or debit card transactions and card numbers,and (iii) bank account information. Various kinds of other informationmay also be maintained, such as for example, information from other useraccounts, past transactions, odometer readings, tax information, imagesof receipts, contacts (e.g., business cards), and online reports.

The system 100 includes a record processing module 110, the database120, and one or more modules to facilitate processing of images ofrecords submitted from users. As an example, a given user can capture animage of a receipt, and submit the image 103 to the service, where it isstored in the database 120 and linked with the user service account.When the image input 103 is received, the record processing module 110processes the image data using, for example, one or more opticalcharacter recognition (OCR) processes 112. The record processing module110 can make a determination from the output of the OCR 112 as towhether sufficient information items have been extracted from the imageinput 103 in order to process the record.

In particular, the records that are conveyed by image input 103 can beclassified by kind or type. Furthermore, based on the classification,the records can be associated with a particular financial resource ofthe user. Among other functionality, the records provided through theimage input 103 can be analyzed in order to generate reports, includingexpense reports or other information. Alternatively, some kinds ofrecords may link to financial accounts of the user. As examples, a cashreceipt can be associated with a portion of a user's account thatreflects cash expenses. Credit card receipts can be associated as anexpense, and with the corresponding financial account on which thecredit card is drawn. Odometer readings can link to expenses of theuser. A travel itinerary can be provided with the users account throughsystem 100, and optionally be assigned as an expense of the user.Business cards can also be linked with the user account through system100.

Record Processing with OCR and Sufficiency

The record processing module 110 may identify different sets ofinformation items as requirements of sufficiency in order to properlyprocess a record of a particular kind for an intended purpose. Thus, thetreatment of the record through system 100, as well as informationneeded from the record, can be determined from the classification of therecord conveyed in the image input 103.

According to some embodiments, the OCR 112 operates to determine a firstset of information items about the record depicted in the image input103. If sufficient information is determined from OCR 112, the recordcan be stored in the database 120 and associated with the appropriateuser financial resource. If however, insufficient data items aredetermined from OCR 112, one or more embodiments provide for use ofadditional programmatic and/or semi-programmatic resources forfacilitating determination of additional information items for properlyprocessing the record.

Classifying Record Depicted in Image Input

Initially, record processing module 110 can use a classificationcomponent to make a determination as to the classification 113 of therecord conveyed through the image input 103. The classificationcomponent 158 (shown as classifier 158) executes to classify thefinancial transaction or event represented in the electronic record. Forexample, the electronic record can correspond to an image of a receiptof a financial transaction, or it can correspond to a business card orother record or event (e.g., travel itinerary or an odometer reading).

In some implementations, the classification component 158 is configuredto classify the information contained in the record to additionalgranularity. For example, for receipts of financial transactions, theclassifier 158 may classify the business establishment or merchant asbeing of a particular kind (e.g., restaurant, store etc.).

In various embodiments, the classification component 158 can use avariety rules, processes and techniques in order to determine theclassification 113 of the record. For example, image processing and/orOCR 112 can be utilized in order to determine preliminary information111 about the record. For example, the geometry of the record canindicate that the record is a business card, particularly if the OCRoutput identifies seven or ten digit numeric codes (e.g., correspondingto phone numbers). Likewise, the presence of dollar amounts or wordslike “cash” can be highly indicative of a record that is a receipt. Inthis way, the classification component 158 may use a set ofclassification rules 159 in order to determine the type or kind ofrecord, based on partial or preliminary information 111, which includesrecord characteristics that are highly indicative of a particular typeof record. In this way, the record conveyed by image input 103 can beclassified as a receipt, odometer reading or business card.

In some embodiments, the record processing module 110 can determine whatinformation would be sufficient to appropriately process the recordbased on the determination of the record type. Specifically, someembodiments recognize that different types of records can requiredifferent types of information items. For example, the information thatwould be deemed sufficient for receipts include a total dollar amountand a date of transaction. Business cards, on the other hand, wouldrequire a name and phone number. Likewise, if the record is recognizedas an odometer reading, the record processing module 110 would notattempt to determine, for example, a total amount of the transaction ora date, but rather a mufti-digit number.

Embodiments recognize that image input 103 can be a low qualityreproduction of a record. In an embodiment, the OCR 112 attempts toextract sufficient information to enable the salient information itemsof the particular type of record to be determined. For receipts,sufficient information items would include, for example, a total amountof the transaction, the date of the transaction, and the merchant orvendor that was a party to the transaction. For business cards,sufficient information would include information corresponding tocontact name, and a phone number and/or e-mail address. If theinformation determined from the OCR 112 is insufficient, then otherresources can be used to attempt to determine information items that areneeded to sufficiently process the record.

Use of Transactions Listed with User Accounts to Augment or ReconcileDeterminations

More specifically, if the OCR 112 fails to yield a result that includessufficient information, embodiments provide for the use of additionalresources to determine the information items of the record. Suchadditional resources can be external (or extrinsic) to the image input,or even to the record depicted by the image. System 100 can include auser-specific transaction analyzer 138 that can provide informationitems 139 for determining some or all of the information items that notdeterminable. In particular, the transaction analyzer 138 cancommunicate with a database 160A which maintains transaction entries 157as provided from various financial institutions and account managers(e.g., online credit card or checking/debit accounts) of the individualusers. In this way, the transaction analyzer 138 can reference theuser's account information (e.g., credit card information) with thedatabase 160A to determine transaction information 155. In particular,the transaction information 155 can include transactions that identify adate, a merchant or an amount. However, embodiments also recognize thatthe transaction information 155 can misstate the date of the transaction(e.g., the date can be the business day that follows the transaction, orthe date that the financial institution of the merchant reports), thename of the merchant (e.g., the name of the merchant can be abbreviatedor altered) or even the total amount (e.g., state restaurant billwithout tip).

In some embodiments, the transaction analyzer 138 includes augmentationlogic 136, (e.g., rule-based logic) to analyze transaction information155 and determine information items that would supplement informationdetermined from OCR 112 or other sources. In particular, augmentationlogic 136 can determine additional information that may not have beenincluded on the image data of the receipt but is contained in, forexample, the transactions 157 of the user. For example, if a receiptdoes not include the merchant's name, augmentation logic 136 can beconfigured to determine, based on transaction information 155, themerchant for which the receipt was generated. In yet another embodiment,a merchant may not actually debit or credit a financial account of theuser until two or three days after the date posted on the receipt. Insuch cases, augmentation logic 136 can be configured to search a daterange associated with the image data on the receipt in order to find amatching transaction. If a matching transaction is found within the daterange, augmentation logic 136 can automatically approximate or insertthe date of the receipt to correspond to the date reflected by theparticular transaction entry 157. As another example, the transactioninformation 155 can identify a specific merchant on a date that iswithin a date range specified by the record under analysis, while therecord processing module 110 is unable to decipher the merchant nameusing other processes such as OCR 112. The identification of the recordname can then be used to augment the results of the OCR 112.

In variations, the transaction analyzer 138 can provide clues fordetermining some or all of the information items that are not otherwisedeterminable from the output of the OCR 112. For example, in the casewhen the image input 103 is for a cash receipt, the transactioninformation 155 can attempt to fill-in for the name of the merchant byidentifying a list of likely merchants based on past-purchasing behaviorof the user. The transaction information 155 can also identify a likelygeography or locality of the user (e.g., zip code) to enable the recordprocessing module 110 to narrow the names of possible merchants.

In the case of a credit card receipt, for example, a date range may bedetermined from the OCR 112 for querying transaction entries 157. Themerchant on the receipt may be matched to a particular transaction entrybased on, for example, the OCR 112 determining a total number of lettersthat are the same as that of a given transaction entry. For credit cardreceipts, the transaction analyzer 138 can augment the output of the OCR112 by providing, for example, the name of the merchant (or anidentifier for the merchant name).

As an addition or variation, embodiments recognize that the OCR 112 canhave an error rate, particular as to the use of low quality inputimages. As such, the transaction analyzer 138 can also be used toreconcile or verify the determinations of the OCR 112. The transactionanalyzer 138 can include verification logic 134 that utilizes thetransaction information 155 to reconcile information contained on thereceipt data with the information provided by the transaction entries157. For example, if the image of the receipt is from a restaurant, butthe image data associated with the receipt did not include the tip,verification logic 134 can retrieve transaction information 155 thatidentifies the total amount for the meal including the tip. As such,when generating the expense report, the true cost of the meal will bereflected. Additionally, rule-based logic may be used to check, forexample, dates, names or total amounts of receipts. For example, if acash receipt is scanned and determined by the OCR 112 to be for aparticular merchant, the OCR determination can be verified (despite thehigh error rate) if the merchant is one that the user has previouslytransacted with, as determined from the transaction entries 157.

Use of External Data Sources to Supplement Determinations of InformationItems

In some embodiments, the record processing module 110 may also accessone or more external data interfaces 148 to supplement information thatwas programmatically determined. The external data resources can includeinterfaces to specific databases, such as Yellow Pages, business namedirectories, travel databases, and other information which a recordprocess module 110 can use to verify or augment the results of its OCRprocessing. In one embodiment, the external data interface 148 accessesa business directory database 160B to check extracted data items 163,such as the name of the business entity as determined from the OCR 112.

An output of the external data interface 148 can include external data121 that includes information items that supplement information itemsdetermined from other sources, such as through OCR 112. For example, theoutput of the external data interface 148 can include a business entitywhich completes a data item of a receipt, in which the output of the OCRcould not identify the business name of the entity involved in thetransaction.

The processing rules and logic 118 can enable verification of the OCR112, if certain criteria is met as between the results of the OCR 112and the results of querying the business directory database 160B. Forexample, if the business directory database 160B includes a businessentity that matches the results of the OCR 112 and which is in alocality associated with the user, then the results of OCR 112 can beconsidered verified.

If the image corresponds to a business card, the record processingmodule 110 can incorporate or otherwise utilize functionalitycorresponding to the classification component 158. For example, suchfunctionality can determine, based on information items 163 from thebusiness card, card information 165, such as the type of businessassociated with the individual named on the business card. In anotherembodiment, the classification component 158 can include or otherwiseutilize a business card database 162 to determine, based on extracteddata items 163 (e.g., an email address on the business card), whetherthe individual named on the business card is a user of the system 100.If the email address is not already associated with user of the system100, the user who submitted the business card may receive referralcredits to their account.

Similarly, if the financial transaction information includes an odometerreading, the record processing module 110, or other programmaticresources of system 100, can determine from the image data, a mileageamount at the start of a trip, the end of a trip, or at any point duringthe trip. This data may then be used to generate an expense report forthe user who submitted the image data.

In some examples, the external data interface 148 can includeprogrammatic resources that operate to supplement the information itemsthat are determined from an image of a travel itinerary. For example,the record processing module 110 can execute to determine the date andflight number of the user's travel based on the image input 103. Oncethis information is received, the external data interface 148 can accessan external flight database to determine a time of the travel, as wellas the flight origination and/or destination. Such information may thenbe used to automatically generate an amount of miles traveled (e.g., foruser's reward program), a price of the ticket and/or an expense reportthat includes the travel information.

Human Task Force Utilization

Embodiments recognize the inherent limits of using low-quality images todetermine information items from images of records. Often, it is notpossible, or practical to rely solely on programmatic resources in orderto decipher the contents of a record, as depicted in a low-qualityimage.

In some embodiments, system 100 includes a human management interface140 that enables work force of humans to perform bulk tasks in relationto determining information about records, as portrayed in a collectionof images provided by the user base. While the human workforce canprovide a high quality output, it typically comes at a significantlyhigher cost as compared to programmatic costs. Embodiments recognizethat the cost for using the human workforce can be reduced if the tasksassigned to the human workforce can be minimized and/or specialized. Forexample, rather than having humans view an entire receipt, a humanworkforce can focus on more discrete tasks, such as for determining orverifying merchant name on receipts. Moreover, embodiments can providefor use of the human workforce in response to failure (or high errorrate possibility) from the programmatic sources.

Accordingly, some embodiments described herein use programmaticresources to focus the tasks assigned to the human task force. In thiscontext, the record processing module 110 and/or the human managementinterface 140 can include functionality that, for example, presentsreceipts for human processing, with prompts to focus human input on onetype of information item (e.g., date). In variations, the functionalitycan present the human operators of resource 170 with records in whichanalysis for information items is partially complete (the date and totalamount is determined, but the name of the merchant is not). The promptsto the human operators can identify information items that areundetermined following programmatic analysis. Still further, humanoperators can be utilized to verify programmatic determinations ofinformation items, particularly those information items that aredetermined with a higher than average or acceptable rate of error.

In one embodiment, the record processing module 110 utilizes the humanmanagement interface 140 for cases in which the record wasprogrammatically analyzed, but with partial and/or insufficientinformation items being determined from the programmatic analysis. Incertain embodiments, record processing module 110 identifies individualtasks that are handled by components of the system 100, and/or two ormore human operators as provided from the human resource 170. It is alsocontemplated that tasks may be handled by a combination of theprogrammatic resources of system 100 and the human resource(s) 170. Forexample, a task associated with receipt data may be to determineadditional data about the received financial transaction and/or toclassify the financial transaction.

In certain embodiments, the record processing module 110, or otherprogrammatic resources of system 100, presents the various images ofrecords from the various user base to be processed in bulk by a humantask force. The individuals of the human task force can use the humanmanagement interface 140 to provide input as to what is depicted by theimages of the various records. In some embodiments, the task force isspecialized, or separated into groups that are specialized, to focus ona particular aspect of the individual records. For example, a particularindividual or group of individuals that comprise the task force canfocus on determining the transaction dates appearing on the record tocorrect or augment information items determined from the OCR 112 and/orother programmatic resources of the system 100.

The human management interface 140 can include a set of human interfacerules 142 to programmatically implement (i) determinations as to whentasks are submitted to the human task force; (ii) determinations as tohow the tasks presented to the human task force can be structured ororganized to enable specialized or dedicated use of the human taskforce; (iii) logic to resolve conflict or discrepancies between theoutput of the human task force and the programmatic resources; and/or(iv) logic to resolve conflict or discrepancies amongst human operators.

In certain embodiments, once the required information has been input bythe two or more resources, and/or the associated financial transactionhas been selected from the financial database 160, the human resource170 can include the two or more workers to perform the same or similartask on an electronic record. The completed information 147 from eachworker is compared and/or combined to determine accuracy and similarity.In certain embodiments, the comparison is performed programmatically,such as by way of a human comparison component 144 of the humaninterface 140. As discussed above, information 147 provided to the humancomparison component 144 may be generated by each of the workers. Assuch, the information of each resource is compared and/or combined todetermine accuracy.

If each of the workers of the human resources 170 have not providedsufficiently similar responses (e.g., the transaction amounts are notequal), the human interface rules 142 and/or comparison component 144can provide for the task of determining data corresponding to thefinancial transaction and classifying the financial information to atleast reassigned one other worker and the process repeats. This processcontinues until a threshold number of resources have analyzed thereceived data or until at least two workers have similar orsubstantially similar data corresponding to the financial transaction.If a maximum threshold number of workers have been reached and no twoworkers have matching information 147, the data associated with thefinancial transaction is deemed to be illegible and the data isdiscarded.

If however, the human comparison component 144 determines that theinformation 147 from at least two workers are the similar orsubstantially similar, the information 147 is assumed to accuratelyrepresent the image information received from the user. As a result, anexpense report that includes each item contained in the image data maybe generated.

As described by various embodiments, the human management interface 140can provide the record processing module 110 with a task force output145 that includes (i) information items that supplement those determinedprogrammatically, including those information items which are otherwisenecessary for processing the record but were undeterminable byprogrammatic resources; and/or (ii) corrections or verification ofinformation items that were programmatically determined.

Applying Image of Record for Expensing and Other Uses

As described, the record processing module 110 is able to utilize avarious number of resources in order to determine a set of informationitems that are necessary for processing the record. As noted, someembodiments provide for processing individual records using a set ofinformation items that are determined based in part on the type ofrecord (e.g., credit card receipt, cash receipt, travel itinerary, orbusiness card). In some embodiments, the record processing module 110generates a record 150 based on depictions of records in individualimages 103. The record 150 can be linked to the user account maintainedthrough a service of the system 100. Additionally, the record can beapplied to an information or data representing a resource of the user.For example, transaction receipts can be applied against amountsdetermined from financial accounts of the user. The records 150 for aparticular user can be accumulated and made part of expense accountingfor the user, or otherwise link to financial assets or obligations ofthe user.

In some embodiments, the record processing module 110 generates a record150 using information items that are provided from differentprogrammatic resources, including the OCR 112, the user transactionanalyzer 138, and human resources 170. In formulating the record 150,the record processing module 110 may utilize different rules or logicfor assembling information items. In one implementation, the necessaryinformation items for a given record are aggregated from each source,assuming no conflict as between an output of the different sources. Ifconflict exists (e.g., OCR 112 is in conflict with human task forcedetermination), processing rules and logic 118 may provide for (i)prioritizing one determination over another (e.g., human task forceoutput outweighs OCR 112), and (ii) implementing a second check, such asan additional round of human analysis by the human task force, or by ahighly trusted human worker. The record processing module 110 mayoperate identify when such conflicts exist, and resolve them based onthe processing rules and logic 118.

In some variations, the comparison logic 114 can be implemented as partof the record processing module 110. The comparison logic 114 canoperate to (i) compare results of information items from two or moresources, (ii) identify conflicts, or (iii) identify when results of onesource augments or reconciles (or verifies) results from another source.

Still further, some embodiments enable the record processing module 110to selectively access various resources for determining the informationitems that are part of the record 150. For example, if the results ofthe OCR 112 or indeterminate as to a particular information item, aresource selection logic 116 may operate to determine the unknowninformation items using such other sources. For example, transactions157 can be analyzed from a database in order to determine merchant nameor date ranges, and yellow page directories can be consulted todetermine merchants. As described previously, such information can beobtained and used to supplement our augment the programmaticdeterminations of information items for the particular record 150. Oncethe record 150 is determined from the image input 103, the record can belinked with the user's account on the service provided by system 100.The database 120, for example, can store the record in connection withthe image of the record. The record and its image can subsequently bemade available to the user for expense reports, reimbursement receipts,or other request of the user.

Optionally, the record can be associated with a particular type oftransaction, or even with a specific event. Transaction logic 154 canprocess the record and assign the record 150 to a particular type oftransaction (e.g., taxable expense). One or more transaction rules 153can be used to determine a transaction or transaction type.

Methodology

FIG. 2 illustrates a method for determining a record depicted by animage input of the user, according to one or more embodiments. A methodsuch as described by FIG. 2 can be implemented using a system such asdescribed by an embodiment of FIG. 1. A computer system such asdescribed by FIG. 4 is used to implement a method as described.Reference to components or elements described with other figures isprovided for purpose of illustrating a suitable component for performinga step or sub step being described.

In some embodiments, image input is received from a user (210). Forexample, system 100 may operate a service to receive image input fromits user base. The image input can include captured images of receipts,business cards, odometer readings, travel itineraries or other recordsthat the user wishes to store with their user account, maintainedthrough the service of system 100.

The image of the record is processed by the system (220). Various formsof image processing can be implemented. In some implementations, theprocessing can identify information about the media (e.g., a piece ofpaper corresponding to receipts, business card, odometer on vehicle) ofthe record depicted in the image input (222). This identification caninclude determination of geometric properties, character layout, and/orcharacteristic text items indicative of a particular class or type ofrecord (e.g. indicative of credit card receipt). Additionally, theprocessing of the image of the record can include optical characterrecognition of alphanumeric characters appearing on the record (224).One or more optical character recognition algorithms can be used todetermine words, numbers, amounts or other special characters (e.g.,‘$’).

Embodiments recognize that the use of camera phones and tablets canyield low quality image input from the user base. For example, paperreceipts may not be framed or oriented, or wrinkled when the usercaptures an image of the receipt. As such, additional processingresources are used in order to determine the information items forindividual records. To this end, embodiments recognize that the use ofOCR and other image processing techniques can be insufficient fordetermining the required information items for processing records ofimages. Accordingly, in addition to image analysis, one or moreembodiments provide for the use of resources extrinsic to the imageinput for purpose of determining information items from the recorddepicted in the image (230).

The use of such sources and data can be used to augment the informationitems determined from, for example, OCR or image processing (232). As analternative or variation, the use of extrinsic resources can be used toverify the programmatic determinations made through image processing, orthrough use of other resources as described below (234).

As described in various embodiments, the extrinsic sources foraugmenting and or validating information items of records include a userspecific transaction source (e.g., transactions made on credit cards,debit cards, or online checking accounts by the user) (242). Forexample, to process receipts for transaction, the information items thatare needed include the date of transaction, the total amount, and thename of the entity involved with the transaction (e.g., merchant). Ifany of the information items are not determinable from programmaticimage analysis, other extrinsic resources can be utilized to identifythe data items. The data items can be identified based on informationdetermined from, for example, image analysis. For example, the imageanalysis can yield a date on a receipt. The date on a receipt, forexample, can be used as criteria to query a database of user's financialtransactions over a given date range in order to identify merchants whomay have provided the receipt in question.

In variations, the query may seek to identify clues as to the identityof merchant. For example, if the OCR yields only a partial name of themerchant, the transaction entries of the database 160A can be used todetermine the locality of the user during the date range. From the daterange, the identity of the merchant can be guessed, based on merchantsthat are in the same locality and whom have the partial name determinedfrom the image analysis.

Likewise, in many cases, information items determined fromprogrammatically processing the image input can be verified through theuse of user specific transaction database 160A. For example, the set ofcharacters that are identified as a date on an image of a receipt can beverified through comparison against a transaction database that containsa transaction with the same merchant on a date that is within anacceptable range from the programmatically determined date.

Another extrinsic source can include external lists of merchants, suchas provided by yellow page directories or other business directories(244). For example, the name of the business entity a receipt, the nameof a person or business card, the company identified a business card,travel itinerary information and various other information items can becross referenced to business directories. The cross-referencing of namesand businesses can either augment information not otherwise determinedfrom a record, verify information that is determined through, forexample, OCR. In the latter case, verification can take place if theprogrammatically determined name matches an appropriate name in abusiness directory.

Still further, the image of the record to be processed by human taskforce (246). In particular, the image of the record can selectively becommunicated to human task force, particularly when the image input doesnot lend itself to programmatic analysis that can identify all necessaryinformation items contained in the record from the image input. Thehuman task force can determine information items and/or verify thedeterminations made through programmatic analysis. As described withother embodiments, the number of tasks assigned to the human task forcecan be minimized to conserve on costs.

Based on the processes described, an electronic record copy can bedetermined for a record of an image input (250). The electronic recordcopy can be stored with the user's online account (e.g., for a serviceprovided through system 100) (252). The electronic record copy can alsobe attributed to a financial resource of the user (254). For example,the electronic record copy can be assigned to a user's cash resource,online credit card or banking. The electronic record can also becategorized (256). For example, the record can be categorized as anexpense, as a tax deductible (or non-tax deductible) expense, as apurchase, or as miscellaneous. Still further, in some embodiments, theelectronic record copy can be reproduced in a manner that meets someestablished criteria (258). For example, the criteria can provide forthe reproduction of the electronic copy to be acceptable by the InternalRevenue Service.

Human Resource Management

FIG. 3 illustrates a method for managing human resources in processingtasks related to images of records, according to one or moreembodiments. A method such as described by FIG. 3 can be implementedusing a system such as described by an embodiment of FIG. 1. A computersystem such as described by FIG. 4 is used to implement a method asdescribed. Reference to components or elements described with otherfigures is provided for purpose of illustrating suitable components forperforming a step or sub step being described.

An embodiment such as described by FIG. 3 can be implemented to managehuman resources and matters cost-efficient and effective. Morespecifically, embodiments recognize that human resources can process andunderstand information items on an image of a record better thanprogrammatic resources, but that human resources accomplish such tasksat a greater expense. Recent developments in developing mechanicalinterfaces for computing environments enable services to rely on apopulation of humans to accomplish specific discrete tasks which humanscan presumably do better than machines. An example of such humanresource is Amazon's Mechanical Turk. To human resources in theseenvironments can be relatively unknown entity step process tasks inbulk. As such, issues of quality can arise. For example, while the tasksassigned to the human resources can be discrete or even trivial, thesheer number of task can incentivize cheating, particular as to the factthat most of the participants in the human resource interfaces get paidbased on the number of tasks that are completed.

Accordingly, one or more embodiments recognize the propensity for humanerror when human resources are used. A method such as described by FIG.3 can be implemented to ensure that in the context of analyzingelectronic records (e.g. financial receipt); the human resource outputcan be relied upon for quality and security.

Initially, task can be assigned to sets of human resources (310), withhumans duplicating some or all of the tasks of other humans. Forexample, a first person in the human resource pool can be assigned afirst set of tasks. The first set task can also be duplicated to asecond or third individual.

Each task can correspond to a discrete action that a human is to takewhen viewing an image of a record such as a receipt. Variations may beimplemented on the manner in which the task is assigned. In oneembodiment, tasks correspond to a particular type of data on a specifickind of record. For example, a task can correspond to determininginformation items corresponding to one of an entity, it date, or a totalcost. According to some embodiments, records can be collected andprovided to human resources in bulk, for the purpose of performing asingle task, e.g., determine the date on each of the records. Byassigning tasks to specific data items, the use of the human resourcecan be made more limiting and specialized, thus saving cost. Invariations, the tasks assigned to the human resources can be todetermine the all information not programmatically determinable fromeach image record, or to verify/determine the information items that areviewable from the image.

The results of duplicate tasks from two or more humans in the humanresource pool can be compared (320). The comparison can be madeprogrammatically. Based on the comparison, a determination is made as towhether duplicate tasks assigned to different humans received the sameresult. To make the determination, programmatic resources track thetasks distributed to the human resource pool, and further record theresults for basis of comparison with results of another human in theresource pool.

For tasks which received the same result from two humans in the humanpool, the result of the task is recorded for the particular record(332). If two humans received different results, those tasks which arein disagreement are assigned to a third human (334). Optionally, thethird human can be one that is known to be credible, based on, forexample, past feedback received for that person. The result of the thirdhuman can be compared against the results determined from the two otherhumans, in order to determine if the third human's result matches one ofthe two prior results (340). If the results from the third human matchesone of the prior results, then the result with two humans in agreementis recorded as the result of the task (342) (e.g., data item on recordis noted by results of the third human when the third human resultsmatch prior result). Otherwise, if the third human returns a differentresult than the predecessors, then no result is obtained (344).

In variations, the process of checking human results with results ofother humans until there is some agreement can be repeated. Moreover,duplicate tasks can be assigned at one time to multiple humans in thepool of the human resource.

Alternatives and Variations

According to some embodiments, a service provided by system 100 cancharge a user for at least some select activities. In certainembodiments, when the image input is for a receipt, travel itinerary orodometer reading, and/or an expense report is generated, a user can becharged for the service to determine information items from the imageinput. In variations, referral credits may be provided to users based onthe information items determined from the user's records. For example,if the image is associated with a business card, and if the emailaddress obtained from the business card does not match an existinguser's email address, the user who submitted the business card may begiven credits as a referral bonus.

Computer System for Implementing Service

FIG. 4 illustrates a computer system on which a service such asdescribed with an embodiment of FIG. 1 may be provided. Morespecifically, FIG. 4 is a block diagram that illustrates a computersystem 400 upon which one or more embodiments may be implemented. In anembodiment, computer system 400 includes processor 404, main memory 406,ROM 408, storage device 410, and communication interface 418. Computersystem 400 includes at least one processor 404 for processinginformation. Computer system 400 also includes a main memory 406, suchas a random access memory (RAM) or other dynamic storage device, forstoring information and instructions to be executed by processor 404.Main memory 406 also may be used for storing temporary variables orother intermediate information during execution of instructions to beexecuted by processor 404. Computer system 400 further includes a readonly memory (ROM) 408 or other static storage device for storing staticinformation and instructions for processor 404. A storage device 410,such as a magnetic disk or optical disk, is provided for storinginformation and instructions.

Computer system 400 may be coupled to a display 414, such as a cathoderay tube (CRT), a LCD monitor, or a television set, for displayinginformation to a user. An input device 416, including alphanumeric andother keys, is coupled to computer system 400 for communicatinginformation and command selections to processor 404. Other non-limiting,illustrative examples of input device 416 include a mouse, a trackball,or cursor direction keys for communicating direction information andcommand selections to processor 404 and for controlling cursor movementon display 414. While only one input device 416 is depicted in FIG. 4,embodiments disclosed herein may include any number of input devices 416coupled to computer system 400.

One or more embodiments are related to the use of computer system 400for implementing the techniques described herein. According to oneembodiment, those techniques are performed by computer system 400 inresponse to processor 404 executing one or more sequences of one or moreinstructions contained in main memory 406. Such instructions may be readinto main memory 406 from another machine-readable medium, such asstorage device 410. Execution of the sequences of instructions containedin main memory 406 causes processor 404 to perform the process stepsdescribed herein. In alternative embodiments, hard-wired circuitry maybe used in place of or in combination with software instructions toimplement embodiments of the invention. Thus, embodiments disclosedherein are not limited to any specific combination of hardware circuitryand software.

The term “machine-readable storage medium” as used herein refers to anymedium that participates in storing instructions which may be providedto processor 404 for execution. Such a medium may take many forms,including but not limited to, non-volatile media and volatile media.Non-volatile media includes, for example, optical or magnetic disks,such as storage device 410. Volatile media includes dynamic memory, suchas main memory 406.

Non-limiting, illustrative examples of machine-readable media include,for example, a floppy disk, a flexible disk, hard disk, magnetic tape,or any other magnetic medium, a CD-ROM, any other optical medium, a RAM,a PROM, and EPROM, a FLASH-EPROM, any other memory chip or cartridge, orany other medium from which a computer can read.

Various forms of machine readable media may be involved in carrying oneor more sequences of one or more instructions to processor 404 forexecution. For example, the instructions may initially be carried on amagnetic disk of a remote computer. The remote computer can load theinstructions into its dynamic memory and send the instructions over anetwork link 440 to computer system 400.

Communication interface 418 provides a two-way data communicationcoupling to a network link 440 that is connected to a local network. Forexample, communication interface 418 may be an integrated servicesdigital network (ISDN) card or a modem to provide a data communicationconnection to a corresponding type of telephone line. As anotherexample, communication interface 418 may be a local area network (LAN)card to provide a data communication connection to a compatible LAN.Wireless links may also be implemented. In any such implementation,communication interface 418 sends and receives electrical,electromagnetic or optical signals that carry digital data streamsrepresenting various types of information.

Network link 440 typically provides data communication through one ormore networks to other data devices. For example, network link 440 mayprovide a connection through a local network to a host computer or todata equipment operated by an Internet Service Provider (ISP).

Computer system 400 can send messages and receive data, includingprogram code, through the network(s), network link 440 and communicationinterface 418. For example, a server might transmit a requested code foran application program through the Internet, a local ISP, a localnetwork, subsequently to communication interface 418. The received codemay be executed by processor 404 as it is received, and/or stored instorage device 410, or other non-volatile storage for later execution.

In various embodiments, system 400 is implemented on a server fordevices such as personal computers, portable computers, and mobiledevices. The system 400 may be operated as a shared platform, such asone that includes a web application operating on a device (and whichcommunicates with a corresponding server application). In oneimplementation, the system 100 may be implemented in whole or in part byuse of a mobile web application.

Although illustrative embodiments have been described in detail hereinwith reference to the accompanying drawings, variations to specificembodiments and details are encompassed by this disclosure. It isintended that the scope of the invention is defined by the followingclaims and their equivalents. Furthermore, it is contemplated that aparticular feature described, either individually or as part of anembodiment, can be combined with other individually described features,or parts of other embodiments. Thus, absence of describing combinationsshould not preclude the inventor(s) from claiming rights to suchcombinations.

What is claimed is:
 1. A method for determining record information, themethod being implemented by one or more processors and comprising thesteps of: receiving a low quality image of a record from a user;communicating the low quality image to one or more resources forrecognizing characters from images, in order to determine a first set ofinformation items provided on the image; identifying a second set ofinformation items that are likely part of the record but notdeterminable from characters provided on the image; utilizing anotherresource to determine the second set of information items; determining aclassification for the record based on the first and second sets ofinformation items; and associating the record with a financial resourceof the user based at least in part on the classification; whereinutilizing another resource includes: (i) scanning a plurality oftransactions recorded with one or more financial accounts of the user;(ii) identifying at least a first transaction that is relevant to therecord, based on the first set of information items; and (iii)identifying the second set of information items from informationprovided with the at least first transaction.
 2. The method of claim 1,wherein the second set of information items includes one or more of amerchant, a transaction value, or a date of a transaction from scanningthe plurality of transactions.
 3. The method of claim 1, whereinutilizing another resource includes querying a merchant or entitydatabase using information that is determined from the first set ofinformation items.
 4. The method of claim 1, wherein the determining theclassification includes determining that the image is a particular typeof financial receipt.
 5. The method of claim 1, wherein associating therecord with the financial resource includes associating the record witha financial account of the user.
 6. The method of claim 1, whereinassociating the record with the financial resource includes identifyingthe record as being a cash transaction.
 7. A non-transitorycomputer-readable medium that stores instructions, which when executedby one or more processors of a computer system, cause the computersystem to perform operations that include: receiving a low quality imageof a record from a user; communicating the low quality image to one ormore resources for recognizing characters from images, in order todetermine a first set of information items provided on the image;identifying a second set of information items that are likely part ofthe record but not determinable from characters provided on the image;utilizing another resource to determine the second set of informationitems; determining a classification for the record based on the firstand second sets of information items; and associating the record with afinancial resource of the user based at least in part on theclassification; wherein utilizing another resource includes: (i)scanning a plurality of transactions recorded with one or more financialaccounts of the user; (ii) identifying at least a first transaction thatis relevant to the record, based on the first set of information items;and (iii) identifying the second set of information items frominformation provided with the at least first transaction.
 8. Thenon-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 7, wherein the secondset of information items includes one or more of a merchant, atransaction value, or a date of a transaction from scanning theplurality of transactions.
 9. The non-transitory computer-readablemedium of claim 7, wherein utilizing another resource includes queryinga merchant or entity database using information that is determined fromthe first set of information items.
 10. The non-transitorycomputer-readable medium of claim 7, wherein the determining theclassification includes determining that the image is a particular typeof financial receipt.
 11. The non-transitory computer-readable medium ofclaim 7, wherein associating the record with the financial resourceincludes associating the record with a financial account of the user.12. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 7, whereinassociating the record with the financial resource includes identifyingthe record as being a cash transaction.